Gå till innehåll

Bok


Klubbsson

Rekommenderade inlägg

Jag kollade vad Amazon . com hade om boken,

Out of Date and sometimes misleading information, December 14, 2004

<TABLE>

<T>

<TR>

<TD vAlign=top>Reviewer:</TD>

<TD>Karen L. White "Raveness" (Cumberland, Maine) - See all my reviews

c7y_badge_rn_1.gif </TD></TR></T></TABLE>I was very excited to start my aquarium and used this book to start, within a few weeks I found out by visiting stores that I was basically doing everything wrong. I went to buy an underwater filter and they laughed at me and told me that they haven't sold any since the 70's. They also fail to mention how important and easy to maintain live rock is. I didn't even get any until a very knowledgeable sales person mentioned it. This book mentions very little about it and even less of it's importance. Overall the book is terrible, I am shopping for something new.

Was this review helpful to you?

< =1.1 =text/>

<!--

showYesNoCommunityResponse(uId,result,value) {

var msg = getElement("thanks" + uId);

if ( result == "SUCCESS" ) {

msg.inner = "Thanks for the valuable feedback you provided to other Amazon.com readers and reviewers. Your vote will be counted and will appear on the product page within 24 hours.";

} else {

showYesNoErrorResponse(uId,result,value);

}

}

//-->

</>

< =1.1 =text/>

<!--

showYesNoDefaultMessage(uId){

.write("<span class='tiny' style='color:#990000;margin-left:5px;' id='" + "thanks" + uId + "'>");

}

function restoreYesNoDefaultMessage(uId){

var msgLayer = getElement("thanks" + uId);

msgLayer.innerHTML = "";

}

function showYesButton(vUrl, uId){

var yesImg = "yes.gif";

document.write(yesImg);

}

function showNoButton(vUrl, uId){

var noImg = "no.gif";

document.write(noImg);

}

function sendYesNoRating(vUrl,uId){

restoreYesNoDefaultMessage(uId);

var voteLayer = getElement('YesNoVotingFrame');

voteLayer.src = vUrl;

}

function showYesNoResponse(uId,result,value) {

var msgLayer = getElement("thanks" + uId);

if ( result == "SUCCESS" ) {

msgLayer.innerHTML = "Thank you for your feedback.";

} else {

showYesNoErrorResponse(uId,result,value);

}

}

function showYesNoErrorResponse(uId,result,value) {

var msgLayer = getElement("thanks" + uId);

if ( result == "BADVOTE" ) {

msgLayer.innerHTML = "There was a problem with your request.";

} else if ( result == "UNRECOGNIZED" ) {

msgLayer.innerHTML = "You must be recognized to vote.";

} else if ( result == "SERVICE-FAILURE" ) {

msgLayer.innerHTML = "There was an error processing your request. Please try again later.";

} else if ( result == "AUTHOR-VOTE" ) {

msgLayer.innerHTML = "We do not allow customers to vote on their own content.";

}

}

//-->

</>

< id=YesNoVotingFrame style="VISIBILITY: " name=YesNoVotingFrame width=0 height=0></>

< =1.1 =text/>

<!--

var uId = '2115|R1IIN5VHKW1Z32helpfulreviews';

var vUrl = 'http://www.amazon.com/gp/vote/ref=cm_r8n_yesno_submit/002-1779763-9518437?%5Fencoding=UTF8&c.1.a.2=0764553402&=if&uri=%2Fexec%2Fobidos%2Ftg%2Fdetail%2F-%2F0764553402&qv=customer-reviews%7C283155%7Cbooks&c.1.label.1.uid=2115%7CR1IIN5VHKW1Z32helpfulreviews&c.1.a.1.=AmazonCustomer&qk=v%7Cn%7Cs&c.1.label.1=helpful&ifRes=showYesNoCommunityResponse&c.1=2115%7CR1IIN5VHKW1Z32&c.1.a.1=A143ANBAM4YZDF&context=reviews&c.1.a.2.=ProductSet';

.write('<nobr> ');showYesButton(vUrl,uId);

showNoButton(vUrl,uId);

docume nt.write('</nobr>');showYesNoDefaultMessage(uId);

//-->

</>

<nobr>yes.gifno.gif</nobr> <NO>

<nobr>yes.gifno.gif</nobr>

</NO>

< =1.1 =text/>

<!--

PopWin(url,name,options){

var ContextWindow = window.open(url,name,options);

ContextWindow.opener = this;

ContextWindow.focus();

}

RefreshOriginalWindow(url) {

if ((window.opener == null) || (window.opener.closed))

{

var OriginalWindow = window.open(url);

OriginalWindow.opener = this;

}

else{

window.opener.location=url;

}

}

//-->

</>

< =1.1 =text/>

<!--

document.write "Report this)" );

//-->

</>

(Report this) <NO>

(Report this)</NO>

<A name=R23UV0X24859PL></A>

<TABLE cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0>

<T>

<TR>

<TD vAlign=top align=left>

10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:stars-2-0.gifDisappointed with Dummies, March 31, 2004

Reviewer: A reader

I bought this book and The New Marine Aquarium: Step-By-Step Setup & Stocking Guide by Michael S. Paletta in order to plan my new saltwater aquarium. The Paletta book is fantastic, up to date and is everything a beginner could want. The dummies book still pushes the undergravel filter as the best method for filtration. About a dozen websites that I checked dissagree. That's my major problem with this book. Having read both books over the course of two nights, I was astounded by how little information you actually get from this book. No subject is given in enough detail, even for a beginner's book. You will see my copy on ebay soon.

Was this review helpful to you?

< =1.1 =text/>

<!--

var uId = '2115|R23UV0X24859PLhelpfulreviews';

var vUrl = 'http://www.amazon.com/gp/vote/ref=cm_r8n_yesno_submit/ 002-1779763-9518437?%5Fencoding=UTF8&=if&uri=%2Fexec%2Fobido s%2Ftg%2Fdetail%2F-%2F0764553402&qv=customer-reviews%7C28315 5%7Cbooks&c.1.label.1.uid=2115%7CR23UV0X24859PLhelpfulreview s&qk=v%7Cn%7Cs&c.1.label.1=helpful&ifRes=showYesNoCommunityR esponse&c.1=2115%7CR23UV0X24859PL&context=reviews' ;

.write('<nobr> ');showYesButton(vUrl,uId);

showNoButton(vUrl,uId);

docume nt.write('</nobr>');showYesNoDefaultMessage(uId);

//-->

</>

<nobr>yes.gifno.gif</nobr> <NO>

<nobr>yes.gifno.gif</nobr>

</NO>

< =1.1 =text/>

<!--

document.write "Report this)" );

//-->

</>

(Report this</TD></TR></T></TABLE>

Påguiden här finns tips på bättre böcker.

Länka till kommentar
Dela på andra sidor

OK, då får jag kolla vidare, jag är ute efter en "lättläst" saltvattensbok Forshags, The modern reef aquarium 1-4 är bra men jag tycker att dom är lite väl ingående och grunderliga när dom tar upp något ämne. Jag vill ha något som även min frågvisa sambo kan läsa.

Länka till kommentar
Dela på andra sidor

Michael paletta´s nybörja böcker är vettiga,Forsså´s alster(dom "Nya")tenderar att bli så teoretiska (läs sömnig kemilektionsaktiga) att det snarare bidrar att skrämma folk från hobbyn (absolut ingen övrig kritik mot den gode Stein)men det är rätt så mycket överkurs,rätta mej om jag har fel!

Länka till kommentar
Dela på andra sidor

Gå med i konversationen

Du kan posta nu och registrera dig senare. Om du har ett konto, logga in nu för att posta med ditt konto.

Guest
Svara på detta ämne...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Ditt tidigare innehåll har återskapats.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Skapa Ny...